Prospect Lefferts Gardens sits on the east side of Prospect Park, just south of Crown Heights across Empire Boulevard. Its blocks of limestone and brick row houses, the single family houses of Lefferts Manor and quick trains to Manhattan keep buyers looking here. Here is what owners should know before selling in 2026.
Prospect Lefferts Gardens at a Glance
The neighborhood runs roughly from Empire Boulevard to Clarkson Avenue between Flatbush and New York Avenues, next to Crown Heights to the north and Flatbush to the south. The Prospect Lefferts Gardens Historic District, designated in 1979, covers much of the row house core, including Lefferts Manor, where many houses carry a long-standing single family covenant that buyers and their attorneys will review.

Housing Stock
- Limestone and brick row houses. Early 20th century houses, many with original woodwork and stained glass.
- Two to four family houses. Popular with owner users who rent a unit and with investors.
- Apartment and mixed-use buildings. Along Flatbush and Ocean Avenues.
Getting around: the 2 and 5 trains at Sterling Street and Winthrop Street, and the B, Q and S at Prospect Park.
What Homes Sold For: Public Records
NYC Department of Finance records show how 1 to 3 family homes traded over the past 12 months compared with the year before.
| Property type | Median, Oct 2025 to Sep 2026 | Sales | Prior 12 months | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 to 3 family homes | $1,865,000 | 58 | $1,870,000 (62 sales) | -0.3% |
About the data. 555 Properties LLC analysis of NYC Department of Finance recorded sales for the Finance neighborhood “Prospect Lefferts Gardens”. Sales under $100,000 are excluded. Medians describe the market, not the value of any one home, and small groups of sales can swing sharply.
Prices held steady year over year, with a similar number of sales. Houses inside Lefferts Manor and on the park blocks often trade differently from the rest of the neighborhood, so close comparables matter.
Selling Your Home Here
- Pricing from the closest sales. Width, block, condition and whether a house is delivered vacant matter more than the neighborhood median. See what is my townhouse worth.
- Lefferts Manor covenant. If your house is inside Lefferts Manor, expect buyers to ask about the single family covenant and how the house is used today.
- Historic district rules. Exterior changes need Landmarks approval. Gather permits and approvals before listing.
- Tenants. Two to four family houses sell differently when apartments are occupied. See selling with tenants.
- Closing costs. Sellers usually pay the NYC and New York State transfer taxes. See NYC seller closing costs.

Recent 555 Properties Sales: Homes and Buildings




See every closed deal on our sold properties page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Prospect Lefferts Gardens part of Crown Heights?
No. It is its own neighborhood directly south of Crown Heights, across Empire Boulevard, and many buyers look at both.
What did houses sell for recently?
Public records show a median of about $1.87 million for 1 to 3 family homes over the 12 months ending September 2026. A private valuation compares your home with the closest sales.
Can I sell a house with tenants?
Yes, but leases and rent rules affect price and buyer pool. Read selling with tenants and speak with your attorney.
