Market reports usually start with averages. This one starts with real closed sales. Over recent months, 555 Properties LLC has represented sellers of six Crown Heights homes, most of them on Carroll Street and President Street south of Eastern Parkway. Together they total $14.82 million and range from a $1.35 million two-family to a $5 million landmark-scale property. Here is what each sale shows about what Crown Heights buyers are paying for.
Six Recent Crown Heights Sales

1337 President Street: $5,000,000
The largest of the group, at about 5,160 square feet, and a property with deep ties to the neighborhood’s history through the Church of St. Mark. Unusual properties need an unusual buyer search, and pricing at this level depends on a clear case for what makes the property unlike anything else on the market.

1428 Carroll Street: $2,600,000
About 2,434 square feet of interior space on a lot of about 2,811 square feet. A well-kept townhouse on a sought-after block shows that condition and setting carry real weight even when the house is not the largest.
1375 Carroll Street: $2,200,000
A legal two-family of about 2,420 square feet, partially semi-detached, with private parking, a backyard, a finished basement and high ceilings. Rental income from a second unit, plus parking, is a combination many buyers look for.

1444 Carroll Street: $2,000,000
About 2,920 square feet of interior space on a lot of about 2,811 square feet, on the same stretch of Carroll Street as 1428 and 1375.
1659 President Street: $1,670,000
A legal two-family brick home with more than 4,000 square feet of living area, a private driveway and a garage. Space and parking at this price point appeal strongly to multigenerational households and owner-occupants who want rental income.
1227 President Street: $1,350,000
The most accessible price in the group, showing the depth of demand across a wide range of Crown Heights housing.

What These Sales Show

- Legal use matters. Several of these homes are legal two-families. A certificate of occupancy that matches the way a house is used gives buyers and lenders confidence.
- Parking and outdoor space stand out. Driveways, garages and backyards are rare in Brooklyn and are consistently highlighted by buyers.
- Condition is visible in the price. Homes with high ceilings, good light and well-maintained systems present better and invite fewer negotiations.
- Every block is its own market. Even within a few blocks of Carroll Street, size, layout and condition separate one sale from the next. Neighborhood averages cannot capture that.
The Bigger Picture
Beyond individual blocks, Crown Heights continues to attract public investment, including the Atlantic Avenue rezoning approved in May 2025. Our Crown Heights Development Watch covers what is planned, and Crown Heights Real Estate 2026 explains how buyers negotiate today. Past sales are not a promise of a future price, and every property needs its own analysis.
Thinking About Selling Nearby?
If you own a brownstone, limestone or two-family home in Crown Heights, see all of our recent sales, read what sellers say about Valerie, or request a private valuation built on comparable sales like these. Learn more about working with a Crown Heights realtor who represents sellers.





