For Brooklyn owners of commercial, mixed-use and income property, the second half of any year is when planning for the next one begins. Property tax notices, appeal deadlines and lease renewals all fall on a predictable calendar, and each affects what a buyer will pay. Understanding that calendar is one of the simplest ways to protect value when you decide to sell.
Know Your Tax Class
New York City assigns every property a tax class, and the class shapes how assessments and taxes are calculated. In broad terms:

- Class 1: most one to three family homes, including many small mixed-use buildings with limited commercial space.
- Class 2: other residential property, including rental buildings with four or more units, co-ops and condos.
- Class 4: commercial property such as stores, offices and many standalone retail buildings.
Because buyers underwrite taxes as an operating expense, a building’s tax class and assessment history appear in nearly every investment analysis. Our guide to selling an investment property explains how buyers value income.
The Calendar Every Owner Should Know

- January: the Department of Finance issues the Notice of Property Value for the coming tax year.
- March: deadlines to request a review from the NYC Tax Commission, generally March 1 for Class 2 and Class 4 properties and March 15 for Class 1.
- July 1: the city’s tax year begins and new bills reflect the final assessment.
Deadlines can shift, so confirm them each year with the Department of Finance or the Tax Commission. If your assessment looks out of line with comparable properties, a timely review request is worth discussing with a tax professional, especially before a sale.

Leases and Timing a Sale
Commercial leases often matter more to value than the building itself. A strong tenant on a long lease suits buyers looking for steady income; a lease nearing its end may appeal to a buyer who wants to occupy the space or re-tenant it at a different rent. Timing a sale around renewals, options and vacancies can open the property to a wider set of buyers. Zoning changes such as City of Yes for Economic Opportunity, approved in 2024, have also widened the range of businesses that can use many storefronts. See Brooklyn retail and mixed-use buildings for more.
What Is Moving in Central Brooklyn
Large public decisions shape the commercial landscape too. In Crown Heights, the Atlantic Avenue Mixed-Use Plan (May 2025) and the 73-99 Empire Boulevard rezoning (June 2025) opened sites to mixed-use development. Read the Crown Heights commercial update and the Crown Heights Development Watch.

Planning Your Next Step
Whether you own a storefront building, a mixed-use property or a walk-up, the right time to plan a sale is before the January tax notice and the next lease decision. Review the Brooklyn multifamily outlook for compliance items, the 1031 exchange if you plan to reinvest, and commercial and investment sales with 555 Properties LLC. When you are ready, request a private valuation from Valerie Sebbag.





